Creed could have been excellent, isn’t

Liked that incredible one-shot fight we did? Well, here’s a slow motion shot of Johnson yelling while he runs! Totally the same thing. Photos courtesy Warner Bros.

Hailed as the best movie of the year, Creed is exactly the kind of overlong, deliriously predictable feature that comes away with its accolades for all the wrong reasons.

The movie follows Donnie Johnson (Michael B. Jordan), the illegitimate son of Apollo Creed (Carl Weathers) from the first few Rocky movies. Johnson is a successful coorporate climber in his early 20s, but gives it all up to pursue a boxing career because, as much as he wants to stay out of his father’s shadow, he also wants to follow in his footsteps. No one will train him, so he moves from Los Angeles to Philadelphia to train under his father’s old rival and friend, Rocky Balboa (Sylvester Stallone) in another display of blatantly taking advantage of his heritage while also saying he doesn’t want to take advantage of it. As Balboa trains Johnson, Ricky Conlon (Tony Bellew), the light heavyweight champion of the world, has an opponent drop out due to injury, and selects the unproven main character to take his place, which, if you remember, is the exact plot from Rocky. 

The problem with Creed has nothing to do with talent or lack of filmmaking ability. Johnson’s second fight, the only truly good part of the movie, proves this, as the two-round bout is taken in all in one incredible shot. The camera circles the fighters intimately, panning to their trainers between rounds and the audience after Johnson’s victory. A feat of pure coordination and skill on the part of the filmmakers and particularly the actors involved, it immediately enters the conversation as best technical boxing scene in movie history.

The rest of the movie has absolutely nothing like it. Director Ryan Coogler gets his kicks in all the wrong scenes, notably with a long, slow-motion shot of Johnson running up the street during his training. It’s dramatic, it’s cinematic, it’s got no real storytelling value. As if to tease viewers, the film features a similar long shot of Johnson getting ready and walking to the ring for his fight with Conlon, and a long, slow-motion shot of Conlon walking into the ring, but the fight itself is shot in boring, conventional boxing movie style. The problem with Creed is a distinct, obvious lack of ambition. They were clearly capable of making a movie that is spectacular in every way, and somewhere along the line decided that wasn’t the priority.

Instead, the priority apparently was to recreate Rocky as exactly as possible, in a way that creates odd parallels between the movie and its title character. Johnson repeats several times that he wants to forge his own legacy in the boxing world, but just as often takes advantage of his heritage. Creed, as a movie, wants to forge its own mythology — read: franchise — independent of its Rocky heritage, but is completely taking advantage of the six movies that came before. It is structurally almost identical to the first Rocky movie. That movie has an iconic training montage, and Creed has three. That movie had a love interest who didn’t really have anything to do with the plot, and Creed has a one, too (Tessa Thompson’s Bianca). The original film hasn’t aged well at all, and Creed feels like just as much of a relic.

Johnson and Creed as a movie both want to create their own legacy. What better way than to stick him in his father’s briefs that have his name emblazoned across the front?

There’s a lot of pandering in this movie, and it gets bothersome. With the most talented black actor under 30 in the lead role and most viewers who remember the series’ original run already sewn up, they obviously go to great lengths to appeal to a young black audience, but not to any real effort. The training montages all have that hippity-hop the kids listen to these days. Special attention is paid to Philadelphia’s apparently thriving off-roaders on roads community. To top it off, of course, there’s that one scene where Rocky doesn’t know what the cloud is.

There’s also some significant Oscar pandering — they give Balboa cancer.

Despite its one transcendent scene, Creed is mostly an unexceptional movie filled with a lot of things meant to fool you into thinking it’s good. If you want a movie with a lot of rap, cancer and slow motion, all used not because they’re the best tools to tell a story or because they’re the best story to tell, but because that’s what the studio heard people respond to these days, you’ll come away satisfied. But if you’re looking for a well-made technical movie, they only did one scene of it.

Leopold Knopp is a formerly professional film critic, licensed massage therapist and journalism student at the University of North Texas. Told ya. I’ve had a change of heart in regard to reader input. It is now welcomed and encouraged. Like Reel Entropy on Facebook, follow it on Twitter @reelentropy, and shoot questions to

This entry was posted in Entropy and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Creed could have been excellent, isn’t

  1. WhittardsLover says:

    My problem with Creed is that the writers gave Adonis (I still think Achilles would’ve been a better name) a gritty background in the first few years of his life to then get adopted by Apollo’s widow anyway BECAUSE he was, for the lack of a better term, ‘Creed’s seed’. If he was going to grow up into a cushy life regardless of his biological mother’s choices or not, why not make him Mary Ann’s child from the start? Like this Adonis would have the burden of his father’s legacy from a young age (especially because of him being born in the year Apollo died) and have a good reason to either follow in his dad’s footsteps or make his own life without boxing – because he would’ve lived in Apollo’s legacy from the very beginning of his life. And there would’ve been no unnecessary gritty background for him in order to be relatable to Rocky and audience. He could’ve come from a rich background but fought tooth and nail for his own legacy you know?

    Being the son of a successful person is never an easy feat (see: Johan Cruyff’s son as a unsuccessful example and Nico Rosberg as a successful one) but at least like that he’ would’ve have a choice to either follow his instincts or break his mother’s heart. In the movie however, Adonis literally DIDN’T NEED to become a boxer. He got a decent job on his own terms without anyone’s help, he was successfully adopted (loved how the Creed family disappeared in the film apart from Mama Creed) and frankly. didn’t need to follow in his Dad’s footsteps. He had everything a guy could want. Why take the risk? “I don’t need help from nobody.” – runs off to Rocky first chance he gets. Lovely. Why didn’t he become a street fighter? Trained by Tommy Gunn? Then caught Rocky’s attention through the bouts? Like that ROCKY would’ve gone to him, not the opposite. (Weren’t Apollo’s trousers Gunn’s property btw?) This movie was pretty much made for people who never watched a Rocky film, but knew the footnotes beat by beat. Also pretty HD Camera lenses. Yeah, gimme Rocky VI over this obvious spin off hook any day.

    PS: I also loved how the relationships of Robert Jr. and Maria were cut from this movie in order to give more screen-time to undeserving Adonis and frankly, boring love interest. Adonis didn’t even have a real nemesis. If you’re gonna re-thread Rocky staples you might as well go all the way. Why not have Adonis fight Ivan Drago’s son Zmey (Sage Northcutt was born for that role) to also include the MMA influence modern boxing has nowadays?

    Hmm. Too much for the posers, I presume. Great review regardless.

    Love, an all time Rocky fan.

    • WhittardsLover says:

      Not to mention it, Adonis didn’t even know he was Apollo’s lovechild until Mary Ann showed up in his life. He probably would’ve grown up to become a forgettable delinquent if that fateful encounter never happened. Or his biological mother could have told him about his heritage eventually and we got to see a 13 year old Adonis literally show up on Mary Ann’s doorstep claiming to be her husband’s son. Oh and some conflict from the other Creed kids cause nobody likes illegitimate siblings at first. There could’ve been many ways to make the story interesting but the writers chose the boring, safe way. “Boxing is in your veins because of your famous daaaad” yadayada.

      Long story short: why is Adonis into boxing in the first place? Because of his dad. But he wants do have none with his legacy. Until it’s convenient to him. It’s a little fanfic-y logic for my liking, but at least we got to see Stallone take a shot at the Rocky franchise one last time. Before he starts making Creed 2: Drago’s Revenge or something.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s